God and Skepticism: A Study in Skepticism and Fideism by T. Penelhum

By T. Penelhum

This e-book is an workout in philosophical feedback. What I criticize are a few diversifications on a recurrent topic in non secular inspiration: the subject matter that religion and cause are so disparate that religion isn't undermined, yet bolstered, if we pass judgement on that cause can provide it no aid. the typical identify for this view is Fideism. these representatives of it that i've got selected to debate do extra, in spite of the fact that, than insist on conserving religion freed from the alleged contaminations of philosophical argument. they give thought to the case for Fideism to be made even better if one judges that cause can't provide us fact or insurance outdoor the field of religion from now on than inside it. In different phrases, they maintain their Fideism by way of an attract Skepticism. I name them, hence, Skeptical Fideists. Skeptical Fideism isn't an insignificant old interest. Richard Popkin has proven us how large its impression within the formative interval of contemporary philosophy has been; and its influence on glossy theological and apologetic reasoning has been substantial. in my opinion, a person who needs to evaluate the various assump­ tions present within the theologies of our time has to take account of it; i feel, accordingly, that there's a topical price in studying the figures whose perspectives I talk about right here - Erasmus, Montaigne, Bayle, and extra importantly, Pascal and Kierkegaard.

Show description

Read or Download God and Skepticism: A Study in Skepticism and Fideism PDF

Best history & surveys books

Routledge Philosophy GuideBook to Husserl and the Cartesian Meditations

Husserl is without doubt one of the most vital philosophers of the 20th century and his contribution to the phenomenology move is largely recognized. The Cartesian Meditations is his most renowned, and most generally studied paintings. The ebook introduces and assesses: Husserl's lifestyles and history to the Cartesian Meditations, the tips and textual content of the Cartesian Meditations and the continued imporance of Husserl's paintings to Philosophy.

A Companion to Latin American Philosophy

This complete number of unique essays written through a global staff of students addresses the imperative topics in Latin American philosophy. Represents the main finished survey of old and modern Latin American philosophy to be had todayComprises a in particular commissioned number of essays, lots of them written by means of Latin American authorsExamines the heritage of Latin American philosophy and its present concerns, lines the improvement of the self-discipline, and gives biographical sketches of key Latin American thinkersShowcases the range of methods, concerns, and kinds that symbolize the sector

Nietzsche and the Question of Interpretation: Between Hermeneutics and Deconstruction

Even if Nietzsche is usually brought up as a forerunner of latest ways to interpretations, little cognizance has been paid to the explicit contributions to interpretation concept present in the Nietzschean textual content. Schrift's well-documented examine rectifies this case. Drawing on assets from classical and modern French, German and English Nietzsche scholarship, this examine specializes in a uncomplicated interpretive difficulty: how one can steer clear of the dogmatic positing of 1 interpretation because the right one with no lapsing into unmitigated relativism during which all interpretations are considered as both valid.

Additional resources for God and Skepticism: A Study in Skepticism and Fideism

Example text

Sebond had tried to give a rational demonstration of the major articles of Christian faith. Montaigne considers two objections to this that had been made by critics. The first is that faith should not be based on reason at all (something Montaigne himself says at the end of the essay). His answer is that within faith CONFORMIST FIDEISM - I 23 reason can be of great service: a manifestly irrelevant response. The second objection is that Sebond's actual arguments are weak. Montaigne answers this by arguing at length, with assistance from Sextus, that the greatest human minds have been unable to find the truth about any subject-matter, so there is no particular reason to be dismayed if the arguments of Sebond are not compelling, since they are as successful as any others are!

It is a confusion, however, from which we can learn. In detecting its sources, it is possible to understand both faith and Skepticism better. The role of reasoning in sustaining the stance of the Skeptic, or the stance of faith, is connected with a second feature in which the two are analogous. It is one which we could not expect the Skeptic to explore, but which the literature of faith has often explored. Not only does each way involve the concerns of the world in which he moves and acts, however different the cause of this distancing may be; each, in so dOing, involves him in distancing himself from those facets of his own being which can undermine the stance he takes up.

1 It is formally a response to an earlier work of Luther's whose title begins with the term 'assertio'. 2 In this work Luther had stated that free choice is a 'fiction', and that the human will makes no contribution of its own to salvation, which is due wholly to the activity of divine grace. Erasmus says at the outset that So far am I from delighting in 'assertions' that I would readily take refuge in the opinion of the Skeptics, wherever this is allowed by the inviolable authority of the Holy Scriptures and the decrees of the Church, to which I everywhere willingly submit my personal feelings, whether I grasp what it prescribes or not.

Download PDF sample

Rated 4.07 of 5 – based on 35 votes